The System Is a Machine Made of Too Many Humans Who Do Not Behave Humane: A Critical Look at the Criminal Justice, Psychiatric, and Educational Systems
In theory, our societal systems are designed to protect, rehabilitate, and educate. However, in practice, they often fall short, becoming cumbersome machines that sometimes fail to act with humanity. This blog post explores how the criminal justice, psychiatric, and educational systems, despite being driven by individuals, often operate in ways that lack compassion and effectiveness.
Criminal Justice System: A Machine of Punishment Over Rehabilitation
The criminal justice system is intended to uphold the law and ensure public safety. Yet, it frequently focuses more on punishment than rehabilitation. The U.S. criminal justice system, for example, is notorious for its high incarceration rates, particularly among marginalized communities. According to the Sentencing Project, the U.S. has the highest incarceration rate in the world, with over 2.1 million people in prison.
Specific Example: The War on Drugs
The War on Drugs, which began in the 1980s, epitomizes the punitive approach of the criminal justice system. Instead of addressing the root causes of addiction, such as poverty and lack of access to mental health care, this policy led to mass incarceration. A study published in The Lancet Psychiatry found that the criminalization of drug use has disproportionately affected communities of color and has done little to curb drug abuse. Rather than rehabilitating individuals, the system has often exacerbated their difficulties, contributing to a cycle of reoffending and recidivism.
Psychiatric System: A Machine That Fails to Nurture
The psychiatric system is meant to provide care and support for individuals with mental health issues. Unfortunately, it often operates as a machine that prioritizes institutionalization and medication over individualized care and compassion.
Specific Example: The Deinstitutionalization Movement
The deinstitutionalization movement of the 1960s and 70s aimed to close large psychiatric hospitals and shift towards community-based care. However, this transition was poorly managed, leaving many individuals without adequate support. A report by the National Coalition for the Homeless highlights that many former patients of these institutions ended up in homelessness or the criminal justice system due to the lack of community resources. Instead of humane treatment, these individuals frequently faced neglect and isolation.
Specific Example: The Use of Psychotropic Medications
While psychotropic medications are essential for many, their use in the psychiatric system is often criticized for being overly prescribed. A study in The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry revealed that patients in psychiatric facilities are sometimes given medication without proper consideration of their individual needs or potential side effects. This can lead to overmedication, dependency, and exacerbation of mental health issues.
Educational System: A Machine of Standardization Over Personalization
The educational system is designed to educate and prepare students for the future. However, its standardized approach often overlooks the unique needs of individual students.
Specific Example: The “No Child Left Behind” Act
The No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB), enacted in 2001, aimed to improve educational outcomes by emphasizing standardized testing and accountability. While the intention was to enhance educational quality, the focus on testing led to a narrowing of the curriculum and increased stress for students and teachers. According to a study by The Center on Education Policy, the emphasis on test scores has often resulted in a “teach to the test” approach, undermining creative and critical thinking skills.
Specific Example: Disciplinary Policies in Schools
School disciplinary policies, such as zero-tolerance rules, can disproportionately affect students of color and those with disabilities. The American Psychological Association reports that these policies often lead to higher rates of suspension and expulsion for marginalized students, contributing to the school-to-prison pipeline. Instead of addressing behavioral issues with understanding and support, these policies frequently push students out of the educational system altogether.
Conclusion: Humanity in the Machine
These examples reveal that the systems intended to serve and protect can often become dehumanizing machines. The criminal justice system, psychiatric care, and educational institutions frequently fail to address the underlying issues that affect individuals, focusing instead on rigid procedures and punitive measures. For these systems to truly serve their purpose, they need to prioritize compassion, individualized care, and rehabilitation over mere functionality. The challenge lies in reforming these systems to ensure that they not only operate efficiently but also uphold the fundamental principle of treating every individual with humanity.
by Dan and Bonkers
SUPPORT MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS TODAY!!!
