Quitting smoking is hard enough without the added pressure of all-or-nothing thinking. Yet, most cold turkey and quitting methods—including 12-step programs—are built on the idea that one cigarette will inevitably lead back to full-blown addiction. They say, one is too many, and a thousand is never enough. This is not just an extreme stance—it’s a dangerous one.
This kind of logic is a well-documented cognitive distortion: All-or-Nothing Thinking. It falsely claims that if you slip once, you’ve already lost, so you might as well give up entirely. But life doesn’t work that way. If you trip while running a race, you don’t go back to the starting line or quit running altogether. You get up and keep going.
How 12-Step Thinking Sabotages Quitting
Programs like Nicotine Anonymous (which I was in for eight years) push the idea that you must never have a single cigarette again—because if you do, you’re back to being a full-blown smoker. The irony? This belief often causes relapses to spiral out of control. Some people stay abstinent for years. Others, convinced that moderation is impossible, fall into a self-fulfilling prophecy of failure.
I lived through this firsthand. After years without smoking, I had one cigarette. The voice in my head, drilled in by 12-step dogma, told me, Well, you’ve ruined it now. Might as well go all in. And just like that, my progress was wiped out—not because of the cigarette itself, but because I had been conditioned to believe that one mistake was a total failure. In Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous, many people end up overdosing and dying this way.
The Truth About Slips and Control
But here’s what I’ve learned since stepping away from that mindset:
- A slip is just that—a slip. It doesn’t mean you’re doomed.
- One cigarette doesn’t have to lead to a full relapse.
- Moderation is possible for many people, despite what the 12-step model claims.
- Slips happen, it can take several attempts to try and not a spiritual experience.
Today’s Progress: This morning, I had a few cigarettes. That's a hard trigger for me. Then I consciously reduced it to one every hour. This means I’ve cut down from three packs a day to nearly half a pack in less than a week. And according to the 12-step crowd, that’s impossible.
Except…it isn’t.
I’m proving, day by day, that breaking free from addiction doesn’t have to be a black-and-white battle between total abstinence and total failure. There’s a middle ground, and I’m walking it—one step at a time.
Final Thought
All-or-nothing thinking is a trap. It’s what keeps so many people stuck in addiction cycles, believing they have no control. But we do have control. And sometimes, success comes not from an instant, perfect quit, but from progress—small, daily victories that build toward lasting change.
Today, I won. And tomorrow, I’ll win again.
by Dan and Bonkers
SUPPORT MENTAL HEALTH AWARENESS TODAY!!!
